Battle of the Brush Cleansers
Tuesday, August 18, 2009 at 7:23PM I love all my make-up brushes. I value them because they cost me some serious money but also because they have helped my make-up application get better so much over the years. As a result I look after my brushes very well and being a freelance make-up artist means I have to keep them in a santized, good condition. This is an indepth review on 5 brush cleaners that are currently available on the market for both regular consumers and professional make-up artists. Y'all enjoy :)
I split my dirty brushes into 5 different groups. Each to be cleaned by a different cleaner. I poured each of the cleaners into a small dish then dipped the brushes into the product, agitated them for a little while and swipped on a paper towel until clean.
Left to right:- MAC Brush Cleanser, FaceSecrets Professional Brush Cleaner, Ben Nye Brush Cleaner, Mehron Brush Cleaner and Graftobian Brush Cleaner
First up...
Graftobian Brush Cleaner £6.16
This is a clear liquid and you can totally tell this stuff has Isopropyl Alcohol in it. It totally reeks and it carries a warning label of "Flammable Liquid".
The good
I really like this brush cleaner. It cleaned its set of brushes very very well. The eyeshadow brushes were completely dry in less than 2 minutes and it took about 4 minutes for the bigger face brush to dry completely. The scent was almost gone when they were done. Left for longer I'm guessing it would disappear. The brushes did feel nice and conditioned afterward. I felt like my brushes were definitely sanitized and it would be good to take with on gigs were you have multiple clients.
The Bad
The bottle is small. 58ml to be precise. The price is a bit steep considering the amount of product you get however I am happy to overlook that considering how well it works. I wish it came in a spray bottle because I find it that much easier to clean my brushes if I'm spraying the product rather than pouring it out. You end up using less but still getting the same effective result. Graftobian does recommend using their brush cleaner in conjunction with their 4 oz dispensing pump bottle. If I ever get a hold of it, I'll let you guys know how it works.
Mehron Brush Cleaner £4.86
You get 133ml of product in the bottle and it has a blue tinge to it. It smells like mouthwash! Honestly. It's kinda minty :) It contains SDA-40 Alcohol which I have come to know is a high grade purified cosmetic alcohol. It does advise on the bottle not to let the brushes stand in the cleaner for prolonged periods of time and it too is a flammable liquid. This cleaner is not tested on animals.
The good
The brushes came out very clean as well with a nice minty scent!
The Bad
This cleaner left what felt like a residue on the brushes. They all took about 5 minutes to dry to 7 mins to dry which could be a problem if you're wanting a quick acting brush cleanser.
Ben Nye Brush Cleaner [Quick drying Spray] £7.30
This is another blue toned cleaner but this one comes in a 59ml spray bottle. It too contains SDA-40 Alcohol and is therefore flammable. It definitely has a scent to and it is noted on the bottle that it must be used in a well ventilated area.
The Good
This cleaner lives up to its word. It is definitely quick drying. It didn't alter the feel of the brushes i.e. no residue and they were ready to use again in less than 3 mins. One of the brushes that was cleaned with this cleaner was a lip brush. Now you all know how sometimes its hard to get the goopy lipglosses and lipsticks off our lipbrushes right? Well this brush cut through that grease and left it spotless. Thumbs up in my books.
The Bad
I really don't like the smell of this cleaner. It is very chemical-ly and it stays on the brushes even when they are dry. If you're not bothered by smells then this would be a good cleaner. Which is why I choose to keep it :)
FaceSecrets Professional Brush Cleaner £4.99
This is a dark blue cleaner that comes in a child safe 118ml/4 U.S. fl oz bottle. It contains SDA-40 Alcohol and is flammable. It is scented. But not as heavily as the Mehron Brush cleaner. It has a shelf life of 12months. It also advises not to leave brushes soaking in the cleaner for extended periods of time.
The Good
The scent on this brush cleaner is alright. It's not overpowering and it left the powder brushes nice and clean. It took a little longer to try. Probably round about the 4 min mark.
The Bad
One of the brushes that was cleaned by this cleaner was a lip brush. This brush cleaner failed to get all the product out of the brush. It got a good amount out but it was still a little sticky afterwards. If you're a professional MUA this won't do. A bit of a disappointment considering they say its a professional brush cleaner
MAC Brush Cleanser £8.00
This is a pink colour brush cleanser. It contains Isopropyl alcohol, is flammable and has a slight scent to it too. Comes in a 235ml large dropper bottle.
The Good
All the brushes came out clean with a slight scent.
The Bad
I'm not sure if this is entirely a bad point. But if you read the how to directions of Mac Brush cleanser it actually says that you need to apply the product to a wet brush, work it through rinse out then leave to dry. So it isn't designed to be a quick drying, on the go brush cleaner. It's more for deep cleaning. In which case you could then compare it to using baby shampoo for example. The brushes cleaned with MAC brush cleanser took more than 5 minutes to dry so I would'nt recomment this cleaner if you're on a make-up gig.
Conclusion
It's always good to have alternatives in your kit if you're a make-up junkie or MUA. Some products work better for others and I hope this post helped you to see what choices you have in terms of brush cleaners. Now I do know that there are a few more out there that I can review but I'll get to those later. I thought these would be good to start off with.
Personally I liked the Graftobian brush cleaner the most, followed by the Ben Nye then the MAC Brush Cleanser. I'll be carrying the Graftobian and Ben Nye in my kit for on the go jobs and when I'm home I'll use MAC Brush cleanser. The Mehron and FaceSecrets Cleaners aren't bad but given the choice I would pick the ones I've mentioned already.
Stay Blessed lovlies xxx
Jesus love you :)
Ben Nye,
Brush Cleaner,
Brush Cleanser,
FaceSecrets,
Graftobian,
MAC,
Mehron 


